The Rainmaker’s Playbook: Attracting and activating top performers

Rainmakers drive revenue, build reputation and can help define the future of a law firm. However, too often firms struggle to unleash the full potential of the laterals they hire. So how can firms better identify, hire and integrate rainmakers to drive sustainable growth? A recent webinar—co-sponsored by Totum Partners and Deacon hosted by leadership coach Gavin Sharpe—explored this topic.

Key Insights

Lateral hiring remains essential – but is fraught with challenges. Despite 96% of firms viewing it as their most effective growth strategy, many lateral hires underperform or fail, often due to poor integration, misaligned expectations, or clients not following the partner to their new firm.

Firms must look beyond the ‘book of business’. Focusing solely on promised revenue overlooks the importance of the individual behind it. Traits such as collaborative mindset, strategic thinking and emotional intelligence are often far better predictors of long-term success than client lists alone.

Strategic alignment is the strongest indicator of retention. Successful laterals can clearly articulate why they joined the firm, how their practice fits the wider strategy, and how they communicate that vision internally and externally. A lack of alignment is the number one reason partners leave.

The lawyer personality profile presents challenges for rainmaking. Research shows lawyers tend to score high on scepticism and autonomy but lower on sociability and empathy, traits that can limit business development. Identifying laterals with the ability to build trust, collaborate and adapt is therefore crucial.

High-quality integration determines long-term performance. Effective integration begins before the partner joins, supported by dedicated sponsors and success indicators that go beyond financial metrics to include collaboration, cross-selling, cultural engagement and internal relationship-building.

Cultural fit underpins sustainable growth. By asking probing questions during the hiring process, such as what might get in the way of success, firms can uncover potential risks early and ensure new partners are aligned with the culture, expectations and way of working.

Hiring a rainmaker is not about buying revenue, it’s about aligning strategy, culture and personality to unlock long-term, firm-wide growth. Firms that invest in deeper assessment, thoughtful integration and ongoing support are far more likely to activate the full potential of their lateral hires.

For a copy of the full report please contact May Ffitch.